Click for Mac Memory Specials!
Click for Mac Memory Specials!


A Click shows your site support to my
Sponsors
Accelerate Your Mac!
Cats-n-Dogs Living Together
by Alex Koyshman
8/18/98

Issue 3- Dogs in the Cats Lair

I remember a number of years ago a controversy over campus-wide MIS standardization at the university I was attending. The issue was simple- The MIS department decreed that there will be no further Mac purchases and all existing Macs will be replaced with PCs as the funds were allocated. Their reason? The Macs did not connect to their central Unix servers, and formed their own independent networks that the administrators couldn't connect to. Mind you that there was never any budget to hire a MAC system administrator, but the problem justified spending thousands of dollars with replacements. Granted, most departments using Macs at the time didn't really mind too much- there was no loyalty to the Mac by that point at our engineering or compsci departments. But I was in the graphics department- and we let our opinions be heard. Following enough posturing, yelling, and claiming funds, the DEPARTMENT got an exemption and obtained the budget to buy 2 labs with the brand new PowerMacs. As time went on, the graphics department added 3D to the curriculum. All the sudden, a few NT Boxes with 3D Studio showed up. Since the entire department was now Macs, the NT boxes had no direct access to any network or printer resources- And left the graphics department scratching their heads with frustration (they were shunned by the campus MIS who wanted nothing to do with those infernal artists and their stupid toys)

This story is not unique by any measure. As most Mac users know, Macs work, and generally very well. Its just a shame that misconception and ignorance prevent otherwise perfectly capable managers from properly utilizing equipment they already have- and already works, and instead opting to push to replace it with untested, unproven replacements! The fact is, there are a handful of cross platform software, some of which has been around for quite a few years that make PC to Mac interoperability as easy as pie.

While I grant you that before Windows 3.0 there was no practical way for Macs and PCs to interoperate, each new version of Windows made connectivity better or more capable. There are two mainstream products available for PCs that allow for Connection into a AppleTalk network. The first is called MacLan (www.miramarsys.com) It is available for 3.1, 95/8, and NT. In a nutshell, it provides full AppleTalk services to PCs- all chooser functions are available directly from the explorer shell as if they are just another Windows resource, and provide for an AppleTalk file and print sharing of PC resources to be available on the rest of the network! Resource forks are dealt with in a rather primitive solution, but it does work- every time a mac file is written to a PC resource, Maclan writes the resource fork to a file with the the same name as the original except it adds a .res extension. The other PC-Mac software is called COPSTalk (www.copstalk.com) and is essentially an Appletalk and Appleshare IP client for the PC, with no server functionality. The peer to peer implementation is the same as Maclan, with all Mac resources appearing as if they are in the Windows explorer shell. Version 2.5 (the latest shipping version) offers full Appleshare IP 5.0 client functionality, allowing PC's to be fully integrated into an Apple Workgroup Server environment. I have used both products; they both function pretty much as advertised.

MEA CULPA

In my last column I wrote that Novell servers do not support long filenames or resource forks for Mac clients. Several readers pointed out that there is, in fact, a complete solution for long filename and resource fork support that comes out of the box for all Novell versions since 3.11 (at least). It's a feature called Mac namespace, and several readers expressed their satisfaction with its usability. It appears that this feature is also available to allow long filename support for other clients, such as Win95/NT and Unix clients as well. Forgive my ignorance, I was using Novell when long filenames were a pipe dream...

My next column will deal with Linux connectivity and will be a bit late. I am on a business trip to Nashville for a week (any nashville readers out there? Where are the good bars?!) Until then, happy computing.

I welcome all questions and comments at akoyshman@jps.net or designamics@jps.net

Back Issues:


Back to XLR8YOURMAC.COM

Disclaimer: The opinions/comments expressed here are the author's alone, and do not necessarily represent those of the site publishers.
Read the site Terms of Use.